LabanPHLabanPH — home

Editorial · Opinion

A cease-and-desist is not a penalty

An app can message your mother, post your face online and call you a criminal. If the SEC catches up with it, it gets a letter.

LabanPH Editorial Team · November 8, 2026

Your contacts get a text saying you are a thief. Your photo turns up on Facebook under the word "SCAMMER". The app behind it was never licensed to lend you a peso. Under Philippine law, that is a crime: the Lending Company Regulation Act forbids lending without SEC authority, with fines of ₱10,000 to ₱50,000 and up to ten years in prison [1].

What actually happens is a letter. The SEC's main weapon against unlicensed lending apps is the cease-and-desist order: an instruction to stop. As reported in May 2023, it had issued them against 58 online lending apps and revoked the registration of 2,081 lending companies [2]. In the same report, the SEC counted eight criminal convictions since 2017. The eighth was about falsified registration papers, and each defendant paid ₱10,000 [2]. That is less than some of these apps collect from one borrower.

We could not find a single reported conviction of an online lending app operator for lending without a license. Not one. If there is one, show us and we will print it here.

A new name costs nothing

An order names an app. An app is a logo and a store listing. Its owners can have another one live within a week. Borrowers who write to us describe exactly this: the name on the texts changes, the threats do not.

And the order only looks forward. Money already taken stays taken. The borrower whose family was harassed gets nothing from an order telling the app to behave from tomorrow.

The law already has teeth. Use them.

Since 2022, the SEC and the BSP have been able to order lenders to hand over their profits and to repay consumers [3]. Wilful violations carry one to five years in prison, and the directors and officers responsible are personally liable [3]. So when did the SEC last make a lending app repay the borrowers it harassed? If it has, it should publish it.

Collection abuse? ₱25,000 for a first offence, ₱50,000 for a second [4]. A rule that costs less than a week of collections is not a rule. It is a fee.

What we are asking for

1. Prosecute unlicensed lending as the crime it already is [1], and publish every case and its result.

2. No stop order without a refund order. If an app lent, it accounts for what it took and pays it back [3].

3. Go after the people, not the logo. Name the directors behind every revoked company, and bar them from lending again.

4. Show the follow-through. For every order: was the app taken down, was anyone charged, was anyone repaid?

5. Make lenders post their prices. We asked eleven pawnshops and lending apps for theirs, and our pawnshop and lending-app pages show who answers.

Until then, a cease-and-desist is not a punishment. It is a rebranding cost.

This is opinion. It states the view of the LabanPH Editorial Team about laws, regulators and industry practice. Factual statements are linked to their sources below; if one is wrong, tell us at complaints@labanph.org and we will correct it.

Sources

  1. RA 9474, Lending Company Regulation Act of 2007, Sec. 4 and Sec. 12 (Lawphil)
  2. BitPinas, "SEC Gets 8th Conviction vs Illegal Lending Firm", 18 May 2023
  3. RA 11765, Financial Products and Services Consumer Protection Act (2022), Secs. 6(d), 15, 16 (Lawphil)
  4. BusinessWorld, "Corporate regulator cracks down on unfair debt collection practices by financing, lending firms" (SEC MC 18, s. 2019), 23 Aug 2019